My favored damaging reexamination is " Scadu approval are dumb pls do nt do this again From " ( They are n’t dumb )
Elden Ring Shadow of the Erdtree is currently suffer one of the more rummy fates in modern gaming : it has realize stellar critical acclaim and is move serious transcript while receiving amazingly mixed user reviews on Steam . chronicle will show it is n’t the first FromSoftware DLC in such a position , however .
beautify with the title " Universal Acclaim " and an impressive aggregate sexual conquest of 95 on Metacritic , Shadow of the Erdtree is certainly enjoy its status as a critical darling . And before long before the much - anticipated DLC released on June 21st , 2024 , the floor Elden Ring biz reach a intellect - boggle 25 million copies sold . You ca n’t debate with those number .
Yet in what sense like a parallel universe , Shadow of the Erdtree has garner a " Mixed " substance abuser reviewrankingon Steam from 42,746 review as of writing . While gripes concerning the enlargement ’s punishing trouble grade are to be somewhat require , the bulk of thecomplaintsare focus on the game ’s poor execution on PC . Players are reporting that their framerate pearl to 30 or lower during certain boss battles – even for actor on high - end rigs .
But it ’s the constant framerate stutters that are specially debatable for a secret plan that is so focused on preciseness and timing . I myself know serious stuttering back in 2022 when I began playing the al-Qa’ida Elden Ring . So much so that I had to set it away for several months before returning to it and finding my issues to have mostly been resolve .
I am already seeing people post random things like chemical attraction change , hardware gadget handler tweak and more to affect the public presentation in Elden Ring : Shadow of the Erdtree . A little wind : the problem is not in your PC , the problem is From Software being bad at their jobs .
Image via Bandai Namco
Dark Souls III Ashes of Ariandel DLC was also hit hard on Steam
But if we look back to October 2016 , when Elden Ring developer FromSoftware free the Ashes of Ariandel DLC for their hit biz Dark Souls III , we can see that this championship too waspannedby user on Steam , with 2,254 negative reviews equate to 3,273 incontrovertible revaluation . The DLC is currently sitting at a 71 on Metacritic right now , garnering a " sundry or ordinary " critics score . This is n’t just agreatscore , and speaking candidly from personal experience , it ’s absolutely deserved . For a DLC that was n’t trying to go for theenormous scalethat Shadow of the Erdtree has to offer , instead prefer for a more focused and contained experience , the cracks on show in ash of Ariandel feel more foundational .
ash of Ariandel was the first major DLC released for Dark Souls 3 , and it did n’t set a great precedent . One of the first and most shocking issues with it was its incredibly poor overall playtime . For anyone with a mid level character , you could push through the entire package in an hour or two , which turn over the weighing machine of Dark Souls 3 , and see the hefty price tag of $ 15 ( which has n’t seen much in the manner of simplification despite being nearly a decade old ) , mass feel perhaps more than a small robbed .
It ’s not as if those handful of minute were particularly exciting either , as Ashes of Ariandel had minuscule center ; it was a collection of ( confessedly ) visually impressive surround interlaced with nothing more than a ridiculous amount of hostile , which hadveryannoying tendency to gang up on you , and one very impressive final hirer ( a review article that has been follow up more and more in the negative reviews for Shadow of the Erdtree ) .
Many thespian ( myself let in ) were gall by the clean-cut lost potential , and some warm showcases of that FromSoftware accomplishment we ’ve all grown to revalue . Sister Friede is one of the safe bosses in the entirety of Dark Souls 3 in my opinion , and that ’s a sentiment shared by a portion of the histrion base . Sister Friede ( and her daddy ) offer a challenging combat , congeal in a great arena , with an impeccable soundtrack and a visually and mechanically impressive three phase . But , Sister Friede is often theonlything you ’ll hear discussed at duration from Ashes of Ariandel , which does n’t betoken in particular well as to the quality of the product as a whole .
You could n’t pay me to remember a particular area name , or a particular piece of loot from Ashes of Ariandel , whereas I could recite youexactlywhat I was reckon when I first touched the orchis and got to see the hereafter of Lordran in The Ringed City .
If I were to describe The Ringed City in a single countersign , it would befinal . If I were to describe ash of Ariandel in the same way … it would beforgettable .
Now as for whether or not Shadow of the Erdtree share these take , the answer is a simple-minded no . Shadow of the Erdtree is not a arrant piece of DLC , and it is dead deserving of critique . Thedifficultyand performance issues aside , Shadow of the Erdtree has some wily boss coming upon , unmortgaged residual issues , and some rather unintuitive navigational paths . ( With Shadow Keep coming to take care in that it can conduct to either one of the last gaffer , an end - game surface area , oran other game political boss , and some excess areas to research at any degree . )
Is all of this deserving of the influx of minus inspection it ’s getting ? No , but my hunch as to why Shadow of the Erdtree is fix so much pom-pom on Steam is that in the midst of such shine critical praise and a skyrocketingplayer tally , a comparatively small but extremely point-blank minority of players need to air their grievance somewhere . And what better place to do so than in Steam reviews , where voicing your frustrations can have a palpable effect on a secret plan ’s exploiter review rating ?
What ’s for sure is FromSoftware desperately ask to desex the expansion ’s public presentation issue ( the1.12.2 updatereportedly has not helped ) . What I ’m not so sure about is whether Shadow of the Erdtree ’s " miscellaneous " rating on Steam will last as long as Ashes of Ariandel ’s . Eight eld is a long clip – and a lot can vary in that prison term . Hopefully people soon see the distinct caliber on offer despite the egress , and it can deliver to the military rating it deserves , whilst also ensuring these review article are made known in a constructive fashion .
Curious as to whether someone has achieved a hitless final foreman run in Shadow of the Erdtree ? Then be sure to take a look at our piece on theWorld ’s first hitless Shadow of the Erdtree final gaffer run has been achievedon Pro Game Guides .
